Property photo 1
Property photo 2
Property photo 3
Property photo 4
Property photo 5
4 Beds
4 Baths
2,750 sqft

$1,659,000

25 Johnny Cake Hill Road, Old Lyme CT, 06371

Price per sqft$603.27
Built in1730
Property size2,750 sqft
Property typeResidential

Overview

Active

Listed Aug 31, 2026

Updated 9 days ago

An elegant and lovingly maintained antique colonial situated on 1.2 secluded acres near the Old Lyme Country Club. Recent updates include new landscaping front and back, new hardscaping around the pool deck, a new cedar roof, well tank, and a HVAC system including ductwork. The interior preserves the historic aspects of the home while graciously blending all the amenities of modern life. A formal living room and cozy library frame the front entryway, and lead to a large family room lined with walls of windows and French doors that bring in loads of natural light. Thoughtful classic architectural details throughout the home include wide-plank hardwood floors, custom built-in cabinetry, crown molding, and front and back stairwells. The cheery kitchen is placed conveniently off the dining area, again filled with more windows and French doors leading to the outside patio. With plenty of room for outdoor seating and dining, it is the perfect spot for entertaining friends and hosting family gatherings around the in-ground gunite pool and spa. A lush lawn beyond beckons for yard games and playing fetch with the dog. Upstairs are four distinctive bedrooms. The primary suite has an ensuite bathroom and walk-in closet. There is another bedroom with a second ensuite bath, and two more rooms that share a third bathroom.

$11,037/mo

Est. mortgage payment based on a $1,659,000 home price.

All estimates are provided by Luxury Presence for informational purposes only. Actual amounts may vary.

Additional information

MLS® ID
24201784

Interior Features

Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
4
Fireplace
Yes
Cooling
Yes
Heating
Yes
Basement
Yes

Exterior Features

Lot Size
1.2 Acres

Other Property Details

Taxes
$13,714
Tax Frequency
Annually
Pool
Yes
MLS provider logo

Listed by Susan Malan with William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l (860) 767-5011

The IDX display contains information sourced from SmartMLS, Inc. as of 9/6/2026. This information is for personal, non-commercial use only and may not be used for any purpose other than identifying properties the viewer may be interested in purchasing. MLS data is generally considered reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Buyers are responsible for verifying all information and should conduct their own investigation or consult a professional. Some MLS data may have been provided by sources other than the listing agent. Unless stated in writing, the Broker/Agent has not verified information obtained from outside sources. The Broker/Agent may or may not have been the listing and/or selling agent, and cannot guarantee the accuracy of any property location shown on a map. Any offer of compensation is made only to participants of the MLS where the listing is filed.

©2026 SmartMLS, Inc. All rights reserved.

Data last updated on 9/6/2026 at 2:22 AM UTC.

Powered by Luxury Presence